Refuting ‘Bad Faith’ Claims in Trademark Registration: The Role of Commercial Records 🕵️♂️📁
“They stole my brand!” In such scenarios, how can you say “I’m innocent!”? Here’s the power of commercial records!
Hello!
You’ve registered your trademark, and now your competitors are suing you, claiming “This name was registered in bad faith!” Don’t panic! Because your commercial records might be your strongest weapon to refute such claims. How? Let’s grab the sword of the law and swing it together!
What Is a Bad Faith Claim? 🚩
Bad faith means that you allegedly registered a trademark with the intent of unfair gain or harming a competitor. For example:
-
Registering a mark that your competitor intended to use, before they could.
-
Trying to profit from a similar name to a famous brand, “accidentally.”
The Turkish Patent and Trademark Office (TURKPATENT) considers such actions as “violations of commercial fairness.” So how do you prove your innocence?
Commercial Records: The Key to Your Evidence Vault 🔑
Commercial records are documents that prove you used your trademark with good faith and for legitimate commercial purposes. Here are the three most critical types:
| Record Type | How It Helps | Example Document |
|---|---|---|
| Invoices | Shows how long you’ve used the trademark | Sales invoices issued since 2020 |
| Advertisements | Proves your marketing efforts with the trademark | Screenshots of social media ads |
| Client Contracts | Demonstrates that the mark is actively used in business | Distributor agreements, dealership documents |
Case Example:
In 2022, a textile company registered the trademark “Ege Silk.” A competitor filed a lawsuit claiming “They registered it in bad faith!” The company won the case by submitting continuous sales invoices, marketing emails, and trade show participation certificates dating back to 2018. The decision was based on TURKPATENT’s relevant regulations.
4 Steps to Refute Bad Faith Claims 🛡️
-
Create a Timeline:
Organize your documents (invoices, ads) chronologically to show when you first started using the trademark. -
Gather Proof of Commercial Activity:
Client emails, order forms, shipping documents… The more proof, the stronger your defense! -
Visualize Trademark Use:
Emphasize the “actual use” of your trademark with product photos, in-store visuals, or packaging designs. -
Obtain an Expert Opinion:
Get a report from an independent trademark expert confirming that your commercial records do not indicate bad faith.
Why Are Commercial Records So Important? 🧠
-
Tangible Proof of Good Faith: It’s how you say, “I didn’t just register the trademark, I actively used it!”
-
Protection Against Statute of Limitations: In Turkey, bad faith claims are typically filed within 5 years. Older records help dismiss such claims.
-
Builds Credibility in Court: Digital documents (e-invoices) with SHA-256 certification are considered more reliable in court.
Inspiring Stat: According to 2023 data, 82% of companies that submitted commercial records successfully refuted bad faith claims! 🎉
Top 3 Common Mistakes and Life-Saving Fixes 🚨
-
Mistake 1: Relying solely on the trademark certificate.
Fix: Prove use prior to registration. “First use date” is golden! -
Mistake 2: Not keeping old documents.
Fix: Archive all documents via cloud storage (Google Drive, Dropbox). -
Mistake 3: Submitting only one type of document.
Fix: Use a mixed set—invoices, ads, and customer feedback.
Conclusion: Saying “I’m Right” Isn’t Enough—Prove It! ⚖️
Bad faith claims can put your trademark and reputation at risk. But well-kept commercial records serve as an umbrella in the storm. Remember: the law doesn’t believe what’s said, it believes what’s proven!
Bonus Tip: Document your trademark use annually with notarized minutes. It’s like nuclear deterrence against bad faith claims! 💣
FAQs 🙋♂️
-
What if I don’t have old invoices?
Get support from your customers or bank statements. Even “indirect evidence” can help! -
Are digital ads accepted?
Yes! Reports from Meta Business Suite or Google Ads are admissible in court. -
How long does a bad faith claim process take?
On average 6–18 months. See TURKPATENT’s Legal Disputes Guide for details.
Hope this guide helps bring peace of mind while protecting your brand! See you in the next article… ✨
Sources:
